What happened
Theguardian.com reported that in 2024, the buy-now-pay-later company Klarna replaced hundreds of customer service roles with an artificial intelligence chatbot, aiming to save millions. After customers complained about the degraded quality of customer service, Klarna began recruiting human customer service agents back. However, these new human agents were hired in an 'Uber type of set-up' as contractors rather than full-time employees, with the AI chatbot continuing to handle basic queries while a growing number of locals manage the more advanced ones.
Fewer Steady Jobs, More Task-Based Work
The experience at Klarna offers a clear look at how AI might change the kind of work available to locals. When the company first used an AI chatbot, it was to handle customer service queries. But when human help was brought back, it wasn't for the same full-time positions as before. Instead, locals were hired in what was described as an 'Uber type of set-up,' handling only the more advanced issues, while the AI continued to manage basic questions. This suggests that AI isn't simply replacing entire jobs, but rather taking over specific, routine parts of them.
For homeowners looking to hire help, this could mean finding locals who specialize in very particular tasks. If AI can handle the simple parts of a job, the human help that remains might be focused on the complex, unique, or difficult aspects. For example, a local who used to do general home repairs might now be called upon only for the trickiest fixes, leaving simpler tasks to be handled differently. This shift could mean less opportunity for locals to build long-term, steady work relationships based on a broad range of skills, and more focus on completing one specific task at a time.
The Hidden Costs of "Flexible" Help
The source material highlights that this new way of hiring, often called 'gig work,' gives locals some choice over when and how much they work. But it also means they miss out on most of the benefits that come with full-time employment. These benefits include things like paid time off, health insurance, workers' compensation, overtime pay, or even a guaranteed minimum wage. Companies integrate AI and shift to this model primarily to save costs, as mentioned in the report.
For locals doing the work, this means less financial security. The report from Human Rights Watch detailed how workers have found themselves in precarious situations, noting that some delivery workers got into car accidents and had to pay their own medical bills because they lacked workers' compensation. Others spent long, unpaid hours waiting for tasks. For homeowners, while this model might seem to offer cheaper services in some cases because companies are saving money on benefits, it can also lead to less reliable help. A local without a safety net might be less able to work if they get sick or injured, potentially affecting their availability or the quality of their work over time.
Who's Really in Charge? Algorithms and Control
The Klarna CEO described the new setup as one where locals can 'jump on and work' like someone driving for Uber. This idea often comes with promises of being your 'own boss' and setting your own schedule. However, the source material points out that the reality for many is different. Platforms that use this model exert a lot of control over the work. This control comes through algorithms, which are used to assign tasks, set pay rates, and evaluate how well the work is done. This means the 'flexibility' often comes with strings attached.
For locals, this means less true independence than the promises suggest. Their work, their pay, and even their performance reviews are often dictated by a computer program rather than by a person or direct negotiation. This can make it hard to understand how decisions are made or to get fair treatment if there's a problem. For homeowners hiring local help through such platforms, it might mean a standardized service experience, but less ability to build a personal relationship with the local or to negotiate specific terms outside of what the platform allows. The system manages the interaction, which can limit the direct connection between the person hiring and the person doing the work.
The practical takeaway
Homeowners hiring local help should understand that many locals may be working without traditional employee benefits, which can affect their availability and financial stability. Locals doing the work need to plan for a future where fewer jobs offer employer-provided safety nets and recognize that platforms often control their work through algorithms, despite promises of flexibility.
Questions readers ask
Will AI replace all the work locals do?
The source suggests AI is more likely to take over parts of jobs, especially routine tasks, rather than eliminating entire roles. This can lead to companies hiring fewer full-time staff and more short-term contractors for the remaining human-needed work.
Could this make hiring local help cheaper for me?
Companies adopt this model to save on costs. While some tasks might become cheaper due to reduced labor expenses for companies, the source also points out the unstable pay and lack of benefits for locals, which might affect the reliability or quality of service over time.
How can I be sure the local I hire is treated fairly?
The material highlights that workers in an 'Uber type of set-up' often lack traditional benefits like workers' compensation or a minimum wage. If you're hiring through a platform described as using such a setup, the local is likely working under these conditions. When hiring directly, you might have more opportunity to discuss terms.
Hiring someone local, or looking for local work?
GigNGo is a no-lead-fee local services marketplace — homeowners post what they need, locals nearby respond, and the locals keep everything they earn. It is run by the same team that publishes Kickback Services.
See how GigNGo works